engine rebuild

C

Charles Gould

Guest
The engine has been inspected & what were my most feared report for
the last 2 summers in Celina has happened. ENGINE TROUBLE.

Well, if that is really what happened to your pond, then you MUST
need engine work.
I am not disagreeing with any of these qualified individuals who have
indicated that you need engine work, but you have not listed a proper
diagnosis.
Is it weak on power? Is it low compression? If so, is it due to
pistons, rings, or the top end, like valves? Is it blowing smoke or
losing oil? If so, is it because of bad valves, guides or seals?
It is very easy to say that you car needs engine work, and an entire
rebuilt will likely solve most, if not all of your problems. However,
if your clothes dryer had a bad thermostat, a complete dryer rebuild
would certainly solve that, but a $12.00 thermostat may solve it just
as well.
I am just a very strong believer in proper, accurate diagnosis before
tearing into anything, for two reasons. First to save unnecessary
expense, and second, is that once you introduce new variables before
you properly diagnose a problem, you never really know what solved
the problem, or worse, the problem may not actually be solved.
Yes, a complete drain and rebuild solved your pond problem, but if
the leak was at an external pump, the rebuild may not have solved it,
and if the fitting where the pump feed pipe goes through the liner
was the culprit, the installation of the new liner would certainly
solve it, but you may have also solved it with a little sealer at
that pipe, for a lot less money.
Chas
 
R

rlgreen_55

Guest
--- In amphicar-lovers@yahoogroups.com, "Charles Gould"
<chasgould@...> wrote:
>
> The engine has been inspected & what were my most feared report for
> the last 2 summers in Celina has happened. ENGINE TROUBLE.
>
> Well, if that is really what happened to your pond, then you MUST
> need engine work.
> I am not disagreeing with any of these qualified individuals who
have
> indicated that you need engine work, but you have not listed a
proper
> diagnosis.
> Is it weak on power? Is it low compression? If so, is it due to
> pistons, rings, or the top end, like valves? Is it blowing smoke or
> losing oil? If so, is it because of bad valves, guides or seals?
> It is very easy to say that you car needs engine work, and an
entire
> rebuilt will likely solve most, if not all of your problems.
However,
> if your clothes dryer had a bad thermostat, a complete dryer
rebuild
> would certainly solve that, but a $12.00 thermostat may solve it
just
> as well.
> I am just a very strong believer in proper, accurate diagnosis
before
> tearing into anything, for two reasons. First to save unnecessary
> expense, and second, is that once you introduce new variables
before
> you properly diagnose a problem, you never really know what solved
> the problem, or worse, the problem may not actually be solved.
> Yes, a complete drain and rebuild solved your pond problem, but if
> the leak was at an external pump, the rebuild may not have solved
it,
> and if the fitting where the pump feed pipe goes through the liner
> was the culprit, the installation of the new liner would certainly
> solve it, but you may have also solved it with a little sealer at
> that pipe, for a lot less money.
> Chas

Charles,

From what I know regarding Ina's engine from Celina it had zero
compression in 2 cylinders plus it was overheated numerous times due
to fan belt issues or lack of. All 4 cylinder's were getting fuel and
spark however you could take the 2 sparkplug wires completely off on
the zero cylinders with no difference in the engines performance.

Ron Green

>
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
Ken Chambers Entertaining engine rebuild General Amphicar Discussion 0
SNOWBIRD Engine front plate General Amphicar Discussion 0
Jon March Proper engine break-in General Amphicar Discussion 4
mike_israel 2-ton engine hoist for $143 General Amphicar Discussion 0
mike_israel New Search Engine on Amphicar Forums General Amphicar Discussion 2
Jon March Engine compartment - !@# manual scraping. stripping, degreasing, sanding, priming, painting General Amphicar Discussion 6
okey0 multiple questions about re-assembly of the 1147 engine General Amphicar Discussion 2
P cautionary tale (my engine upgrade experience) General Amphicar Discussion 14
okey0 Engine OUT....how to mount on stand now? General Amphicar Discussion 9
mike_israel No Amphi content. Search engine duckduckgo.com General Amphicar Discussion 0
Jacques B. Triumph Spitfire oil pan on amphicar (Herald) engine ? General Amphicar Discussion 3
Akamphi Engine oil priming tool General Amphicar Discussion 3
Akamphi Spit 1500 engine break in. General Amphicar Discussion 1
T Removing the engine, were do you split from transmission General Amphicar Discussion 2
kdroy Water in engine General Amphicar Discussion 4
AHite Possible Engine Conversion General Amphicar Discussion 8
S Pulling an engine General Amphicar Discussion 7
A engine timing and dwell General Amphicar Discussion 3
Midwest Amphicar Engines engines who needs an engine General Amphicar Discussion 4
azpaul50 Engine Cover Luggage rack General Amphicar Discussion 6
Midwest Amphicar Engine cover holes or how I spent today General Amphicar Discussion 1
B Re: Engine cooling fan General Amphicar Discussion 0
B engine cooling fan General Amphicar Discussion 2
amphicarian Engine advice General Amphicar Discussion 19
DavidC Amphicar engine in Alabama General Amphicar Discussion 0
C Best way to install engine/ transmission General Amphicar Discussion 3
A engine milage and mechnical status General Amphicar Discussion 7
K Engine compartment paint. General Amphicar Discussion 2
B SV: Re: engine and transmision - Clutch Chatter Cause?? General Amphicar Discussion 0
W engine and transmision General Amphicar Discussion 4
M Body Part (Rear Engine area) replacement General Amphicar Discussion 1
B seatbelts idea; radiator, engine and transmission for sale General Amphicar Discussion 0
D Parts help engine cover needed General Amphicar Discussion 0
C Underside hull paint and engine compartment paint General Amphicar Discussion 6
G bilge pump switch and engine breather line General Amphicar Discussion 0
W engine manifold mystery General Amphicar Discussion 7
B SV: SV: Re: Engine cooling / Fan noise General Amphicar Discussion 0
B SV: Re: Engine cooling / Fan noise General Amphicar Discussion 1
D engine personalities General Amphicar Discussion 1
W Engine cooling / Fan noise General Amphicar Discussion 6
B 1147 cc engine advice needed General Amphicar Discussion 2
D rear engine seal General Amphicar Discussion 3
J Harley engine ---Lake Ozarks next week General Amphicar Discussion 1
B Engine Dies When Hot General Amphicar Discussion 9
C Fuel Injection on a Triumph Engine General Amphicar Discussion 1
S Wankel Engine in an Amphi General Amphicar Discussion 5
S Wankel Engine General Amphicar Discussion 3
S Engine gasket sets General Amphicar Discussion 1
R rebuilt engine and tranny General Amphicar Discussion 0
M Engine Block Needed General Amphicar Discussion 0
Similar threads


















































Top